Further education learners face EMA axe

Hit in the pocket:
Omari Hope, aged 17 - a first-year student on the National Diploma in Construction course at Barking & Dagenham College.

In his family, Omari Hope is: "looking out for everyone”, and is in receipt of £30 a week EMA.

"Sometimes it's for travel, sometimes it's for the books I need. I don't want to keep asking my Mum, because she's got my little brother to look after. I try to be the responsible one and just buy what I need to buy, without going to my Mum. It could be calculators for my maths, it could be the equipment - it could be anything.

"I give some to my Mum sometimes; I give it to my little brother, if he needs it. I give it to them whenever they need it. They can just take it, because I save it all the time - I rarely spend it. When I do, it's for the equipment I need."

Independence is important to Omari. If EMAs were withdrawn?

"I'd have to ask my Mum for little bits and pieces that I may need for college, and that would put her under a lot of pressure. I don't particularly want that, because I'm growing up - at the moment, I don't feel I need to ask my Mum for anything.

"I think it's ridiculous, to be honest. I thought them putting up uni fees was bad enough, but taking this away is just a bit too extreme."

Omari's message for the PM?

"They should be saving money in other areas, rather than education.How can you be Prime Minister?! These kids need to go to university, they need to get an education. This just might make kids do other stuff for money, stuff that could be illegal."

Thousands of East London students to be ‘cut adrift’ as low-income Further Education students face the scrapping of the Educational Maintenance Allowance. Half of all young students across three FE colleges to lose vital government funding.

The Vice-Chancellor of the University of East London and the Principals of three east London FE Colleges have warned the Government that cuts to funding for FE students are tantamount to cutting East London adrift and abandoning a generation of disadvantaged learners.

1,234 (41%) of 16-18 year-olds currently studying at Barking & Dagenham College, 1,300 (70%) at Tower Hamlets College and 622 (46%) at Hackney Community College are in receipt of the Educational Maintenance Allowance (EMA). Families depend upon this money in order to keep these young people in learning. Under Government proposals, no new students will receive EMA from January and existing students, even those on two-year programmes, will lose their allowance from July 2011. The Government’s promised hardship fund will only offer around 10% of the funding currently available.

This situation is further compounded by the withdrawal of most free training to learners aged 19 and over in receipt of benefits other than Jobseeker’s Allowance and Employment Support Allowance, such as Incapacity Benefit, Lone Parents Allowance, Income Support, Council Tax reduction and other identifiers of poverty. 93% of adult learners at Barking and Dagenham college would be at risk of falling out of learning because they cannot afford to pay the fees.

The government is also due to introduce fees for those learners over 23 years-of-age who do not have a first full level 2 or 3 qualification. Around 30% of Hackney Community Colleges’ 23 year-old and above learners currently receive free tuition.

UEL has strong partnerships with local colleges and devotes considerable resources to ensuring long-term sustainable progression to Higher Education (HE) for those students.  UEL was recently nominated for Widening Participation Initiative of the year at the Times Higher Awards for its information advice and guidance projects to support progression in East London.

Professor Patrick McGhee, Vice-Chancellor of the University of East London, said: “The network of UEL and East London colleges is pivotal in creating opportunity, wealth and employment for hundreds of thousands of residents in some of London’s most deprived boroughs such as Barking and Dagenham, Hackney, Newham, and Tower Hamlets. For many of our students, of all ages, of all groups, we are the most powerful force for economic justice that they will encounter in their lives.

“Funding initiatives such as the EMA and fee-remission for poor residents have a proven track record of improving retention and attainment in FE and increasing progression to HE. To remove these entitlements will serve only to redistribute public funds away from young people and second-chance learners who already have comparatively few opportunities.  In my mind this will devastate East London just as we are beginning to see clear returns on investment in the area.

“We also know that Black and Minority Ethnic (BME) students are more likely to access the EMA than their white classmates.  I have already raised concerns about how the HE fees and funding proposals will disproportionately affect these learners. It is clear such inequalities extend into the proposed FE funding settlement.”

Cathy Walsh, Principal of Barking & Dagenham College, said: “Barking & Dagenham College offers over 10,000 young and adult learners, some from the most disadvantaged communities across the East London region, the opportunity to achieve their career aspirations through high quality learning and training, to secure better jobs for a better life. For many they are the first in their family to be able to progress to college and university.

“Withdrawal of one of the most successful initiatives to keep youngsters in learning and training – EMA’s – in addition to the removal of the entitlement to fee remission for genuinely disadvantaged adult learners, will have a doubly disastrous effect. There will be significantly fewer people able to stay in learning to develop their skill levels. Plus, there will be fewer skilled workers available to fill the local economy’s job market.

“Instead, and though not the planned intention of the Coalition Government, this will have the unintended consequence of preventing thousands of motivated students from disadvantaged backgrounds becoming economically independent because they cannot afford to pay for their studies.”

Ian Ashman, Principal at Hackney Community College, said: “Our colleges have a proud tradition of widening participation, helping those most disadvantaged in society to enter education and make positive life changes.  Working with universities such as UEL, many go on to higher education.  Students need their EMA and subsidised tuition to get the qualifications that they and the London economy needs. These changes will adversely affect local communities and will prevent the Government achieving its objectives of increasing employment and skills in the capital.”

Michael Farley, Principal of Tower Hamlets College, said: “The scraping of the Education Maintenance Allowance will have a significant impact on many Tower Hamlets residents and on the College’s ability to increase the number of young people participating in full time education. For those who do stay on post-16, it may impact on an attendance and eventually on the ability of some to stay to the end of the course.

“Tower Hamlets is a most exciting and vibrant borough. However, it is also a borough with huge social challenges. 50% of children come from benefit-dependent families, and 33% of families live on less than £20,000 per year. Tower Hamlets also has the highest free school meals entitlement in the UK.

“Financial support for young people is a valuable investment towards a sustainable and strong economy for all of us. If, as promised, savings from EMA are focussed on ‘the most disadvantaged children,’ then the Government would be wise to pay attention to the impact this may have in areas such as East London.”

Published Tuesday 14 December 2010

Image shows learner Omari hope, with his thumbs tucked into his pockets
“They should be saving money in other areas, rather than education. These kids need to go to university, they need to get an education.”
- Barking & Dagenham College construction learner Omari Hope, 17.